Advertisement

5 Reasons Android Should Be Afraid of the Palm Pre


January 12th, 2009 by Mark Spoonauer  

combined-image3There’s no question that the Palm Pre was the darling of CES, garnering our Best Cell Phone award, a Best of Show and People’s Voice Award from CNet, and top honors from Popular Mechanics. And as we mentioned previously, several people we spoke to at this year’s show said they would be willing to switch to Sprint to get one. (And that’s saying a lot given the carrier’s recent troubles.) Will the Pre have the impact of the original iPhone? Not likely. But it could very well slow the momentum of Google’s open-source Android software, assuming Palm capitalizes on its CES buzz and executes. In fact, to me the Android camp seems downright nervous. And it should be. Here are five reasons why.

1. Like Apple, Palm gets that a great smart phone requires a tight integration of hardware and software.

During our in-depth, hands-on demo of the Pre, we were impressed by just how well the gestures worked in tandem with Palm’s webOS, and the slide-down keyboard executing universal searches. It’s that same exact marriage of hardware and software that catapulted the iPhone to the number-one selling handset in the U.S. With the first Android-based phone, the T-Mobile G1, many lauded the OS but criticized the phone as being clunky. Will the selection of Android-based devices get better over time? Undoubtedly, but the Pre feels like a device that was built from the ground up, both inside and out. Google is leaving it up to its partners to create great Android phones.

2. The Pre has higher-profile service and content launch partners.

No one will deny that Android has a robust selection of apps, many of which are homegrown, but mainstream consumers are more impressed with name brands. Which is why it was a big feather in Palm’s cap to have Facebook on stage at the Pre’s launch. The Pre’s contact and messaging functionality will have deep ties into the social networking powerhouse. At least for now, you have to go through a third party to get your Facebook fix on Android. On the music front, the Pre will support Pandora, and Android has the less compelling Last.FM. Other heavy hitters in the Pre’s corner include Amazon (which Android has), Fandango, Yahoo, TeleNav, AOL, MobiTV, and DataViz.

3. The user interface is slicker and more consumer-friendly.

Looking at the Pre, it’s easy to see that Palm spent a lot of time paying attention to little details that add up to an interface that’s versatile but also downright fun, even for novices. Many shoppers will stop into Sprint stores just to play with the Pre’s activity card gestures, super-fast accelerometer, and dashboard. The overall UI also looks more colorful and approachable than Android (at least in its current stage). With Android, it can feel like you’re using a different device depending on the program that’s open—and that’s not counting third-party apps.

4. Even Google knows the Pre has a lot of potential.

Given the fact that the iPhone was in development long before Android hit the scene, it’s easy to see why Google is all over Apple’s iconic device, from Maps with Street View to the very cool Google Mobile App, which lets you conduct searches with your voice. The Pre is different. It comes at a time that Android is just gaining steam. And yet Google is very tightly integrated with Palm’s device, including universal search, Google Maps, Google Calendar, and Google Talk. Yes, Google and Palm have long been partners on other devices, but if Google didn’t think the Pre would succeed it wouldn’t bother to offer its plethora of services.

5. Android backers are already on the defensive.

It’s being reported that executives from Australian carrier Telstra are taking aim at the Palm Pre, saying that an Android phone launching in the second quarter from HTC was “better and more functional.” The same execs went on to say that “the new HTC phone will be a real competitor to the iPhone and the Pre, which at this stage looks nice but is still not delivered to market.” The fact that Android backers are already mentioning the Palm Pre in the same breath as the iPhone and feel the need to prop up the OS is a surefire sign that they feel threatened.


 Comments (8 Responses) 

8 Responses to “5 Reasons Android Should Be Afraid of the Palm Pre”

  1. tal Says:

    The fact that their SDK arsenal is made of HTML/CSS and Javascript is enough to show a lack of power for the open community. at least in my opinion.

  2. Khaled Says:

    Tal, that’s rubbish. It’s a show that anyone with web developer knowledge can get in on the app action. You don’t need to learn a whole new set of rules, languages etc to get something done. Without the SDK released you have no clue as to how powerful the applications are likely to be and what limitations they’re likely to have.

  3. tal Says:

    Rubbish or not this is what they are saying on their site: http://developer.palm.com/
    Rubbish or not at least for me this tech is too simplified to run apps which require more powerful coding.
    I am not saying the Android environment is the second coming, but could have been nicer to find the WebOS is supporting some higher level language.

    I like the word Rubbish, but British often sounds childish.

  4. binary Says:

    On the contrary, Javascript doesn’t demonstrate lack of power. It’s just a higher level language that allows any programmer to develop apps in an environment easier to follow and understand (as apposed to reading line-by-line code in Assembly language).

    What matters most is how the code is stored and executed. If the Javascript code remains as a text script and compiled only during execution, it could result in slower performance. However, if the Javascript code is pre-compiled in the Mojo environment (similar to programming in C) into binary machine language that the Palm Pre’s microchip understands in native form, it will function blazingly fast!

    And from the reviews I’ve read, the Palm Pre rocks with respect to response time and speed. If this is true, then it is more likely that the Javascript code is pre-compiled into it’s native machine language to tap into it’s internal registers and ports directly.

    We’ll just have to see for myself when I download the SDK and buy my own Palm Pre ;-)

  5. KingJew Says:

    The PRE is an amazing reentry for a dying breed. The interface is bold and daring. The customization makes this one a winner. Sadly I did not see it at CES. I will add a new number and purchase this through Sprint on release day!!!

  6. TareX Says:

    I was a die-hard Android enthusiast, till I saw the Pre conference. Then, I saw the leaked photos of the G2… which were a huge fail. Then I saw even more videos of webOS in action…. THIS IS THE PERFECT PHONE.

    The only thing I have left in my way is NVIDIA’s Tegra platform. Unless they have an awesome phone lined up with Tegra around the Pre release, then the PRE is my next phone purchase.

  7. ray Says:

    i can’t believe it. The PRE is a horrendous phone. Anyone who’s talking it up has not used it for more than an hour in their own hands. The icons are misplaced, the UI requires too many steps to get to what you want, and simple things like going to your text message and replying or adding a new contact is a tiresome act.

    too many people get starstruck by the fancy lights

  8. Joe Piervincenti Says:

    I agree with the Android enthusiasts. The PRE has a horrendous keyboard and doesn’t give you the option for a touch screen keyboard, even with widescreen view which would be perfect. For some reason though, I dislike the face that my friend with that phone gets YouTube videos with amazing quality compared to my G1 which has an operating system made by the owners of YouTube :(

Leave a Reply

Featured Sponsors